The good: Love the book. Great pictures and descriptions. I'm brand new to foraging and it's written for and intended for people new to mycology and foraging. It also lists 2 websites that are supremely helpful. Very detailed descriptions and lots of great info (like taste descriptors, and whether or not they need to be cooked or boiled before eating, etc)
The bad: it doesnt show ALL available or edible mushrooms in Alberta. There's only about 50 or so listed. And if you're on the hunt for "magic" shrooms, this book does not list them. It also describes what poisonous mushrooms each one may resemble, but doesn't show pictures of the poisonous ones to illustrate the difference. I just like finding mushrooms like a scavenger hunt, so that's not a problem, but if you plan to collect & eat what you find, I'd suggest using an app on your phone or posting a picture of the mushroom in chats or on mushroom-enthusiast websites that help identify them before consuming them.
The ugly: NOTHING! the pictures are absolutely beautiful and overall it's a great resource for someone new to mushroom foraging.