Fantastic! My kids love these. I like how they pour nicely (because the box makes a triangle spout) into a bag to take for a school snack. I thought my kids would not be able to tell the difference from these (extreme cheddar) and the normal cheddar goldfish (which are cheaper). So I bought two bags of the normal cheddar goldfish and poured them into this great extreme cheddar box that pours nicely. They could tell! They did not like the regular cheddar goldfish. They said the extreme cheddar ones were much better tasting. So the dog got the other ones, and he was happy too.