I love the thumbsticks. Get the thumbsticks separately instead. The rings feel like pool noodle Styrofoam. When you stretch them to put them on, they feel like they are ripping apart like a seal on a cereal box. Then once they are on, the idea of them is good. But as you move, it's clear that these things are going to crumb up and into your thumbsticks' ball joint. Hard to remove them without them ripping. I even tried using tools from a cellphone repair kit. But the second stretch was too much for these rings to tolerate and the snapped. If you already have an old controller with stick drift, give them a try. But don't ruin a new controller with these.