I should have been more observant - the item is more like a sample bottle than a legitimate product. But my biggest disappointment was the topping, which had separated into a peanut butter clump and runny fluid. No matter how much I shook it (and believe me, I shook it a lot - vigorously), I couldn't get the contents to blend into something usable. The best I could do was a runny brown liquid. The experience hasn't changed my love for Reese products, but this topping will be not be on my list any time soon.