I bought this with the assumption it would be heavily used, or clearly cosmetically scratched. When it came in the mail, it didn’t come in its original Apple box; but inside had all the original packaging and cords. The case itself is literally scratch free with no scuff marks or any signs of wear & tear (I used to own the first gen Pros for a few years)
On top of that, find my works perfectly, and the inside of the case is completely clean. Maybe I stuck lucky and got a barely used pair! Very happy with my purchase.