I've had the same silver GameCube controller for roughly 20 years. I've used it to play Super Smash Bros. Melee, Brawl, and even Ultimate. Never had a problem... until recently. The A button had become jammed and wouldn't come all the way back up. I guess all the button mashing had finally taken its toll. Luckily, I found these renewed GameCube controllers here. I ordered an indigo controller from rock_30_games because they seem to be the most recommended seller. The controller plays like its brand new and I can now play Super Smash Bros. Ultimate at my best again. This is just the replacement I needed and I am definitely fully satisfied.